Background

Here are the results from a South Atlantic MSE exercise testing the behavior of model-based versus empirical MPs for black sea bass (BSB), vermilion snapper (VS), and red porgy (RP) using the openMSE software (Blue Matter Science).

VS_Overages Results

Below are the results for vermilion snapper (VS) with implementation overages.

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

BSB Results

Below are the results for black sea bass (BSB) with implementation overages.

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

RP_Overages Results

Below are the results for red porgy (RP) with implementation overages.

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs